Lunchtime, Soup and a crying beggar

on life

Have you ever seen a grown-up man cry? I’ve seen myself a few times… But that never invokes the kind of emotion that I experienced today…

I was stuck in office and had almost forgotten about lunch. I noticed around 2 PM and since this-thing-I-was-doing was interesting enough, I thought about getting a quick soup from Specialty’s (it’s one of the 15+ cafe/restaurants near my office) – and when I am in a hurry and not very hungry, I go there… Nice thick soups for around $3-5.

Anyway, so I was just outside when I saw a beggar (it’s usual to see one in Seattle – and IMHO, more so in Seattle than in NYC). On an average, I usually see 1 beggar in a day (maybe because I travel back home around 9 or 10 at night? Maybe my opinion would have changed if I went home earlier, or if I was out around this time more regularly in NYC)
It has become so regular that my instinct has been honed to murmur something like “I am only carrying cards – no cash” with a sad-smile and walk away. I won’t be lying if I say that I really don’t have any cash on me 99% of the time.

But this guy was different – most guys are used to such a reply and give a damn about it. This guy asked me again, “Please if you have any part of a dollar – even a penny” and I could see the pain or the need in his eyes… But I was walking away so fast – my brain could not catch up to my heart.

Once I got the soup I saw this guy again from the window – he was crying now – and I could see the pain in his eyes now again, only much worse. I checked my wallet but I really did not have any cash at all. And I had just paid for the soup with my card. I wanted to help him but did not know how… Anyway, I was still not so emotionally charged as I would be 2 minutes from then and so, started back to the office…

Just when I was about to enter through the door, I HEARD him cry… yes – he was crying loudly now… I felt so bad I stopped and looked back… I felt like giving him the soup I had with me… But before I realized he was already walking away.

Once in the elevator, I felt this sudden depressive emotion – man it was an awful feeling. I wish you never have to see that face or hear that cry/sob – of a grown man in real (emotional) pain.

I remember giving away $20 to a stranger in Jersey City one day – and earning a lot of flak from my friends… But I said it then, and I say it now, this guy looked like he needed the soup/$20 much more than I did.

I know (or at least, I perceive, like most of us) that most of the beggars are well-capable of acting. But what if this guy was not acting?

All this happened in a matter of 4-5 min, but left a lasting sad feeling in me. I know I cannot do anything for that man now but maybe putting this down in a blog will make me feel less guilty?

And a very un-important question – what the hell do I do with this soup now?

2 Comments

2 Comments

  1. Anurag  •  Jan 30, 2008 @03:08

    touching…

    arent we all so used to not giving to people in need…rather…we suspect that the person is just feigning

    it take one man’s tears to move a person…but then many of them…many of us dont express ourselves through tears…for them…its again the same cold stare saying…f*** off

    but again…is giving alms the solution…i dont know
    i just pose questions…n am myself lookin for answers

  2. Arnab  •  Jan 30, 2008 @08:48

    When you express a “f*** off” you are not feeling sad – no way. You are angry, aren’t you? Tell me one scenario when someone in extreme sadness has said “f*** off”?

    Hence somebody saying that to me will never elicit anything but a silent laugh from me (and secretly I’m happy that he/she’s able minded to take it). People (and at the risk of sounding biased, although true without a shed of doubt, man in particular) don’t cry a lot – which is ok – they’ve been brought up not to cry… (I don’t wanna sound like the so called uber/metro sexual anymore so I’ll stop here).

    Yes giving alms is definitely not the solution, if there is one anyway. My Dad has this theory – if a beggar comes to your place (office/home in India) never give it – coz pretty soon it”ll be a regular thing and his gang might come too. If you see him on the street or somewhere random, probably it’s ok.

    Now again, I usually don’t give alms – but this guy touched me man!!!

Leave a Reply

Allowed tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>